Beach Day by Rodger Bliss
November 2019
S M T W T F S
« Mar    
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Max Gaetanno Kidnapping Mystery

Max Gaetanno Kidnapping Mystery
BTS has been kidnapped. BigHit has narrowed the pool of possible kidnappers to 5 fans that were at the meet and greet: Rose, Monica, Nik, Jackson, and Denise. Each of them gave three statements, two of which are true and one false.

Rose
1. I didn’t do it!
2. I’ve never kidnapped anyone in my life.
3. Jackson did it.

Monica
1. I didn’t do it!
2. The kidnapper wore a black shirt.
3. I don’t like Denise.

Nik
1. I didn’t do it!
2. I’ve never seen Denise in my life.
3. Jackson did it.

Jackson
1. I didn’t do it!
2. Denise did it.
3. Rose was lying when she said I did it.

Denise
1. I didn’t do it!
2. Monica did it.
3. Nik and I used to be friends.

Help Max figure out who kidnapped BTS?

Thank you Hobi’s Sunshine Smile for your submission!

Submit your Guess

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

6 guesses to Max Gaetanno Kidnapping Mystery

  • raymond madden

    To Start we need to get each statement and put it together (I didn’t like the way it auto formatted)

    Rose
    1. I didn’t do it!
    2. I’ve never kidnapped anyone in my life.
    3. Jackson did it.

    Monica
    1. I didn’t do it!
    2. The kidnapper wore a black shirt.
    3. I don’t like Denise.

    Nik
    1. I didn’t do it!
    2. I’ve never seen Denise in my life.
    3. Jackson did it.

    Jackson
    1. I didn’t do it!
    2. Denise did it.
    3. Rose was lying when she said I did it.

    Denise
    1. I didn’t do it!
    2. Monica did it.
    3. Nik and I used to be friends.

    Now we need to compile the possible contradictions

    The first one on each line is the same, So one of them is a lie obviously so I will look at options 2 and 3 (and call them 1 and 2 respectively)

    Jackson and rose, Rose said that She has never kidnapped anyone, as well as Jackson did it. Jackson stated Rose was lying when she said the second statement
    If that is the case, Rose 1 is truth, and 2 is a lie. and Jackson’s 2 is truth and 1 is a lie meaning Denise couldn’t have done it
    this is the list updated, as as it is assumed that we found the lie already it means the actual first statement is also true. as well as Denise didn’t do it, based on Jackson

    Rose (Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. I’ve never kidnapped anyone in my life.(Truth)
    3. Jackson did it.(lie)

    Monica
    1. I didn’t do it!
    2. The kidnapper wore a black shirt.
    3. I don’t like Denise.

    Nik
    1. I didn’t do it!
    2. I’ve never seen Denise in my life.
    3. Jackson did it.

    Jackson(Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. Denise did it.(Lie)
    3. Rose was lying when she said I did it.(Truth)

    Denise (Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. Monica did it.
    3. Nik and I used to be friends.

    Now at this point there is 3 people we don’t know for sure the truths and lies for, and 2 people we don’t know who did it or not. Using the next contradiction Nik and Denise as the next point, Nik has never seen Denise in there lives but Denise said they used to be friend. Nik’s number 3 is ‘Jackson Did It’ but based on what we know Jackson cant have done it, meaning that Nik has never seen Denise before in there life. and by deduction meaning Denise’s second statement is truth, and third statement is a lie.

    Rose (Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. I’ve never kidnapped anyone in my life.(Truth)
    3. Jackson did it.(lie)

    Monica
    1. I didn’t do it!
    2. The kidnapper wore a black shirt.
    3. I don’t like Denise.

    Nik (Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. I’ve never seen Denise in my life.(truth)
    3. Jackson did it.(Lie)

    Jackson(Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. Denise did it.(Lie)
    3. Rose was lying when she said I did it.(Truth)

    Denise (Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. Monica did it.(truth)
    3. Nik and I used to be friends.(Lie)

    Now my deduction that Denise’s second statement is truth we are left with Monica who did it, who is wearing a black shirt, and doesn’t like Denise for cracking the case!.

    Rose (Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. I’ve never kidnapped anyone in my life.(Truth)
    3. Jackson did it.(lie)

    Monica (Did IT!!!!!!)
    1. I didn’t do it!(Lie)
    2. The kidnapper wore a black shirt.(truth)
    3. I don’t like Denise.(truth)

    Nik (Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. I’ve never seen Denise in my life.(truth)
    3. Jackson did it.(Lie)

    Jackson(Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. Denise did it.(Lie)
    3. Rose was lying when she said I did it.(Truth)

    Denise (Didn’t Do it)
    1. I didn’t do it!(truth)
    2. Monica did it.(truth)
    3. Nik and I used to be friends.(Lie)

    Monica is now hauled of to jail after some great detective work!

    (This solution could of gone many ways, but as a internet Riddle solver some assumptions had to me made, such as Jackson was the one being truthful not Rose in the third statement, as if it was vice versa, is would of created a mess down the road with everyone lying and having 3 subjects that equally “Did” it, so when you assume at the beginning, it can lead to the truth, and when you look back you can see what could have easily gone wrong if you changed one of the deductions ever so slightly.)

  • Kookies Ironman Socks

    I say Rose or Jackson, possibly Nik but I’ll have to keep mulling over it after I finish rewatching BTS’s 2018 MMA performance, FANTASTIC, I’ve been watching it for the last few hours and I must say I was surprised to see this email, wasn’t expecting fellow armys to be here lol

    Hope the kidnappers didn’t make fun of any of the members socks this time, that was hard to watch amirite :(

    P.S will be back to try this riddle again, every1 go watch BTS MMA 2018 performance if you want to experience Koreas heaven

  • Chloe Key

    Monica because she is the only one who didn’t blame anyone.

  • Unknown

    Denise, because if you look at Rose’s you see that since 1 or 2 had to be true, and one can’t be true while the other isn’t, Jackson didn’t do it. Then when you look at Jackson’s, we see again the same thing with 1&3. So Denise did it.

  • Raymond, you are the winner!!
    Monica is the kidnapper.